White Button Mushrooms
Flavor: Mild, meaty
Texture: Smooth, firm
Price: $
Best ways to cook: Grill, sauté, roast
Cremini
Flavor: Intensely meaty
Texture: Smooth, firm
Price: $
Best ways to cook: Grill, sauté, roast
Portobello
Flavor: Robust, earthy
Texture: Dense, steak-like
Price: $
Best ways to cook: Grill, sauté, roast
Shiitake
Flavor: Nutty, buttery
Texture: Pleasantly chewy
Price: $$
Best way to cook: Sauté
Tip: Look for smaller specimens with thick caps and edges that curl under the caps.
Oyster
Flavor: Clean, savory, subtly briny
Texture: Delicate
Price: $$
Best way to cook: Sauté
King Oyster
Flavor: Very savory
Texture: Resiliently chewy
Price: $$
Best way to cook: Sauté
Black Trumpet
Alias: Horn of Plenty
Flavor: Robust, slightly smoky
Texture: Pleasantly chewy
Price: $$$
Best way to cook: Sauté
Tip: They are a particularly dirty variety and must be thoroughly rinsed. Halve them first to loosen any grit hiding in the centers.
Morels
Flavor: Rich, nutty
Texture: Spongy, meaty
Price: $$$
Best way to cook: Sauté
Tip: Look for mushrooms with minimal grit and be sure to check inside the hollow centers for insects
Enoki
Flavor: Very mild, faintly nutty
Texture: Delicately crisp
Price: $
Best ways to cook: Sauté, deep-fry, stir into soup
Maitake
Alias: Hen-of-the-Woods
Flavor: Nutty, slightly smoky
Texture: Feathery
Price: $$
Best way to cook: Sauté
Chanterelle
Flavor: Assertively nutty, almost fruity
Texture: Dense; fibrous but not tough
Price: $$$
Best way to cook: Sauté