As soon as I open a diner menu, I home in on one word: “Pancakes.” It promises so much sensory delight: the steam that floats from the top of a towering stack, the way that pillowy loft yields to the fork, the satisfaction of swooping the last bite around the plate to swab up every drop of syrup.
And then I order an omelet. Most pancakes aren’t a practical choice for me; though they’re filling in the moment, I’m hungry soon after I eat them. But I have been tempted by the idea of cottage cheese pancakes, which replace the usual milk or buttermilk with a more protein-rich dairy choice—and the promise of a truly satisfying breakfast.
Sign up for the Cook's Insider newsletter
The latest recipes, tips, and tricks, plus behind-the-scenes stories from the Cook's Illustrated team.
Blender Pancake Perks
A blender is a key tool for making cottage cheese pancakes: The whirring blades ensure that even large-curd cottage cheese will melt seamlessly into the batter, and it allows us to include rolled oats, which can be quickly blitzed into a powder, as one of our whole grains.
Most cottage cheese pancake formulas are generous with the cheese and also include eggs that are sometimes whipped to incorporate air into the heavy batter.
I tried that approach, buzzing the cheese and eggs in the blender with melted butter, sugar, and salt. Then, I transferred the frothy mixture to a bowl and whisked in some flour for structure and baking powder for added lift.
The batter looked thick, but once on the griddle, it spread too much. I realized the cheese was the likely culprit: Thick when cool, it was melting with the heat of the griddle, causing further spreading.
So, I doubled the eggs to add more protein for structure.
The resulting pancakes were fluffy and enhanced by a subtle dairy sweetness and tang, but I wondered if I could make them even more flavorful and filling. The answer was to swap the white flour for whole grains.
Whole-wheat flour added nuttiness, and rolled oats, easily reduced to a powder in the blender, contributed more appetite-satisfying bulk.
I also increased the butter for extra richness. As a final flourish, I stirred flavorings such as jam, fruit, or peanut butter and maple syrup into Greek yogurt and dolloped it on top.
Cottage Cheese Pancakes
Creamy cheese and whole grains make flapjacks that are both ultrasatisfying and more complex.
Get the Recipe
