When it comes to your waffle breakfast, the batter and waffle iron are synergistic teammates. But for the batter to perform properly, your waffle iron must be properly warmed up.
Waffles are only as good as the batter and the waffle iron, and while the batter changes depending on your recipe, your waffle iron is your constant, life-long companion. Waffle makers for home cooks come in two main styles: classic machines that make shorter waffles with shallow indents, and Belgian-style machines that make thick waffles with bigger indents. Regardless of style, the best models are easy and safe to use and produce golden, evenly-browned waffles. The key to great waffles is knowing how best to use this piece of equipment.
Preheating a waffle iron is key to producing crispy, evenly browned waffles, and it’s not as simple as waiting for a preheat indicator to signal that the iron is ready. Preheat for longer than recommended. We found that preheat indicators signaled that the irons were ready after about 4 minutes, but that’s not nearly long enough. That’s because preheat indicators rely on a simple sensor that tells you when only one particular area of the iron plate has reached the desired temperature—not when the cooking surface is uniformly hot. For a cooking surface that is heated evenly from edge to edge, we recommend pre-heating the waffle iron (no matter the brand) for at least 10 minutes (or up to 20 minutes if you have the time) before using.
If you’re giving your iron extra time to properly heat at the outset of cooking, it makes sense to allow the iron to recover between batches. In our tests, most waffle irons took between 1 and 2 minutes to rebound to their properly preheated temperatures after a waffle was removed. By giving your empty waffle iron time to heat up again, you yield more consistently golden and crispy waffles and lessen the chances of anemic, soft waffles.
Whether it’s vegetable oil spray, a pat of butter, or oil brushed on, adding a layer of fat to your waffle iron, even ones with a non-stick surface, is a safe bet. Simple waffle mixes without much sugar in them typically fare well in an ungreased waffle iron, but add-ins like chips, fruits, and purees get stuck more easily. Take care to grease your waffle iron plates before each batch of waffles.
Click here to find the best waffle makers.